| Kenneth
Vercammen's Law Office represents individuals and companies involved
in serious litigation matters. In a Civil Suit, a Complaint and Case
Information Statement is prepared by the Plaintiff's attorney. These
are then filed in the Superior Court, Law Division. After the Complaint
is filed, the plaintiff's attorney will prepare a Summons and have
the defendants personally served with the Summons and Complaint. The
defendant generally only has 35 days after service of the Summons
and Complaint to have their attorney file an "Answer to Complaint"
Details on Answer are set forth in the following Rule 4:6-1:
RULE 4:43. DEFAULT Rule 4:43-1. Entry of Default If a party against
whom a lawsuit has been filed fails to file a formal " Answer
to Complaint", failed to plead or otherwise defend as provided
by these rules or court order, or if the answer has been stricken
with prejudice, a default can be requested. The Plaintiff's Attorney
can make a formal written request of the clerk for the entry of
the default, supported by the attorney's affidavit. The affidavit
shall recite the service of the process and copy of complaint on
the defendant or defendants (if more than one, naming them), the
date of service as appears from the return of the process, and that
the time within which the defendant or defendants may answer or
otherwise move as to the complaint, counterclaim, cross-claim, or
third-party complaint has expired and has not been extended. The
request and affidavit for entry of default shall be filed together
within 6 months of the actual default, and the default shall not
be entered thereafter except on notice of motion filed and served
in accordance with R. 1:6 on the party in default. If defendant
was originally served with process either personally or by certified
or ordinary mail, the attorney obtaining the entry of the default
shall send a copy thereof to the defaulting defendant by ordinary
mail addressed to the same address at which defendant was served
with process.
4:43-2. Final Judgment by Default When a default has been entered
in accordance with R. 4:43-1, except as otherwise provided by R.
4:64 (foreclosures), a final judgment may be entered in the action
as follows: (a) By the Clerk. If the plaintiff's claim against a
defendant is for a sum certain or for a sum which can by computation
be made certain, the clerk upon request of the plaintiff and upon
affidavit setting forth a particular statement of the items of the
claim, their amounts and dates, a calculation in figures of the
amount of interest, the payments or credits, if any, and the net
amount due, shall sign and enter judgment for the net amount and
costs against such defendant, if not a minor or mentally incapacitated
person. If prejudgment interest is demanded in the complaint the
clerk shall add that interest to the amount due provided the affidavit
of proof states the date of defendant's breach. If the judgment
is based on a document of obligation that provides a rate of interest,
prejudgment interest shall be calculated in accordance therewith;
otherwise it shall be calculated in accordance with Rule 4:42-11(a).
If the claim is founded upon a note, check or bill of exchange or
is evidenced by entries in the plaintiff's book of account, or other
records, a copy thereof shall be attached to the affidavit. (b)
By the Court. In all other cases the party entitled to a judgment
by default shall apply to the court therefor; but no judgment by
default shall be entered against a minor or mentally incapacitated
person unless that person is represented in the action by a guardian
or guardian ad litem who has appeared therein. If the party against
whom judgment by default is sought has appeared in the action, that
party (or, if appearing by representative, the representative) shall
be served with notice of the motion for judgment filed and served
in accordance with R. 1:6. If, in order to enable the court to enter
judgment or to carry it into effect, it is necessary to take an
account or to determine the amount of damages or to establish the
truth of any allegation by evidence or to make an investigation
of any other matter, the court may conduct a proof hearing or take
such proceedings as it deems appropriate, and in that event, if
the defendant was originally served with process either personally
or by certified or ordinary mail, the attorney for the claimant
shall give notice of the proof hearing to the defaulting defendant
by ordinary mail addressed to the same address at which process
was served. In tort actions involving multiple defendants whose
percentage of liability is subject to comparison and actions in
which fewer than all defendants have defaulted, default judgment
of liability may be entered against the defaulting defendants but
such questions as defendants' respective percentages of liability
and total damages due plaintiff shall be reserved for trial or other
final disposition of the action. If application is made for the
entry of judgment by default in deficiency suits or claims based
directly or indirectly upon the sale of a chattel which has been
repossessed, the plaintiff shall prove before the court the description
of the property, the amount realized at the sale or credited to
the defendant and the costs of the sale. In actions for possession
of land, however, the court need not require proof of title by the
plaintiff. If application is made for the entry of judgment by default
in negligence actions involving property damage only, proof shall
be made as provided by R. 6:6-3(c). (c) Conformance of Judgment
With Pleading; Service of Judgment. Whether entered by the clerk
or the court, the final judgment shall not be different in kind
nor exceed the amount demanded in the pleading, except that in continuing
causes, installments coming due after the filing of the pleading
but before entry of judgment may be added to the amount of the demand
stated in the pleading. Within seven days after receipt of the executed
judgment from the court, the proponent of the judgment shall serve
a copy thereof on the defaulting defendant as required by R. 1:5-2
except that service may be made by ordinary mail alone. (d) Failure
to Apply for Judgment Within Six Months. If a party entitled to
a judgment by default fails to apply therefor within four months
after the entry of the default, the court shall issue a written
notice to the party entitled to apply for entry of default judgment
advising that the action will be dismissed without prejudice when
six months have elapsed following the date of the entry of default
unless within said period the party files application for entry
of default judgment or by affidavit shows exceptional circumstances
for the delay in seeking the judgment. If exceptional circumstances
are shown, the court shall issue an order extending the time for
entry of the judgment for a specified period, which may be further
extended on motion. An application for entry of default judgment
made after the expiration of six months following the entry of default
shall not be granted except on notice of motion filed and served
in accordance with R. 1:6.
4:43-3. Setting Aside Default [Vacating Default] For good cause
shown, the court may set aside an entry of default and, if a judgment
by default has been entered, may likewise set it aside in accordance
with R. 4:50.
The following is a portion of a Motion successfully used by Kenneth
Vercammen's office in Vacating a default:
....... Please Take notice that the undersigned, attorney for
n1, will apply to the above named court, at the m1 Court House,
_____, New Jersey, pursuant to the 5 day Rule and R 6:3-3 for an
Order: To Vacate Default and Permit Defendants to File Answer and
Counter-Claim
Please take further notice that the undersigned shall rely upon
the certification of Kenneth A. Vercammen in support of this motion.
"NOTICE. IF YOU WANT TO RESPOND TO THIS MOTION YOU MUST DO
SO IN WRITING. Your written response must be in the form of a certification
or affidavit. That means that the person signing it swears to the
truth of the statements in the certification or affidavit and is
aware that the court can punish him or her if the statements are
knowingly false. You may ask for oral argument, which means you
can ask to appear before the court to explain your position. If
the court grants oral argument, you will be notified of the time,
date, and place. Your response, if any, must be in writing even
if you request oral argument. Any papers you send to the court must
also be sent to the opposing party's attorney, or the opposing party
if they are not represented by an attorney."
PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that this motion is filed with the
court pursuant to Rule 1:6-2 and that unless an objection by any
of the parties hereto is received within 5 days, or unless otherwise
directed by the court, the movant shall submit the within application
for decision by the court upon the papers and without the necessity
of oral argument.
Dated: ________________________________________________ KENNETH
A. VERCAMMEN, ESQ. Attorney for n1
CERTIFICATION OF MAILING
The undersigned hereby certifies that the original Notice of Motion,
Certification and all supporting papers have been filed directly
with the m1 County Motions Clerk, New Jersey. It is further certified
that a copy of the Notice of Motion, Certification and all supporting
papers have been served by regular mail upon all counsel and individuals
indicated in the Notice of Motion.
Dated: _________________________________ KENNETH A. VERCAMMEN Esq.
Attorney for n1
Certification in Support of Motion
1. I am an attorney at law of the State of New Jersey. I represent
n1 and am fully aware of the facts and circumstances of this Motion.
2. The Summons and Complaint were mailed to defendants in _______
3. They had initial difficulty obtaining counsel.
4. On _________________, I spoke with , attorney for plaintiff.
He indicated he would not object to the default being vacated. A
Consent Order Vacating Default and Extending Time to Answer was
forwarded to plaintiff's attorney. (Exhibit A). -. We have not received
the signed Consent Order. -. Numerous defenses exist to the complaint
as set forth in the enclosed Answer and Counter-Claim. The defenses
are
There is no prejudice to plaintiff if this motion is granted. -
We request the court grant this motion to vacate default and permit
the filing of the Answer and Counter- Claim. I certify that the
foregoing statements made by me are true. I am aware that if any
of the foregoing statements made by me are willfully false, I am
subject to punishment.
Dated: KENNETH A. VERCAMMEN
ORDER TO VACATE DEFAULT
This matter having been opened to the Court upon motion of Kenneth
A. Vercammen, Esq. , attorney for n1 for an Order to Vacate Default
and Permit Defendants to File Answer and Counter-Claim,
and the Court having considered the Certification submitted, documents
attached in support of the Motion, and the argument of counsel,
if any, and for good cause shown,
it is on this _____ day of ______________________
ORDERED that the Default is Vacated and Defendants are Permitted
to File Answer and Counter-Claim
FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this order be served upon all Counsel
within ten (10) days.
_______________________________J.S.C.
The court will not automatically vacate default. We recently in
2004 opposed a Motion to Vacate Default and submitted this brief:
LEGAL BRIEF FOR ATTORNEYS FEES AS CONDITION TO VACATE DEFAULT
The Appellate Division recently ruled attorneys fees are to be
imposed as a condition to vacating a default judgment.
REGIONAL CONSTRUCTION CORP. v . RAY, ___ NJ Super. ____ Decided
December 11, 2003 [A-2510-02T2] in an opinion written by Judge Fischer,
determined attorneys paid to the plaintiff attorney rather than
bond should be required.
Defendant Lawrence V. Ray (Ray) moved to have a default judgment
vacated one month after its entry. His motion was granted on the
condition that a bond be posted in an amount in excess of the judgment.
Because such a condition was neither justified by the circumstances
nor proportionate to any prejudice suffered by plaintiffs, we reverse
and remand.
R. 4:50-1 permits the granting of relief from judgments or orders
"upon such terms as are just." Little has been written
about the application of this aspect of the rule, although it has
been determined that "terms" may include a requirement
that the defaulting party post a bond in the amount of the default
judgment as a condition of vacatur.
It is fair to conclude, from these out of state authorities, that
the imposition of terms pursuant to R. 4:50-1, while discretionary,
should be judged against the relative strength or weakness of the
movant's application and will be sustained only when reasonably
proportionate to the prejudice suffered by plaintiff. The power
to impose terms is not to be used to punish or sanction the defaulting
party. Instead, the power should be invoked when necessary to relieve
the plaintiff of any attending prejudice. Where the only prejudice
to plaintiff has been the expenditure of costs and attorneys' fees
in the pursuit of the default judgment or in responding to the motion
to vacate, then the exercise of discretion with respect to the imposition
of terms should be limited accordingly. This is the type of term
most appropriately imposed and most commonly utilized, as we have
previously indicated. Davis, supra, 317 N.J. Super. at 102; see
also Annotation, Conditioning the Setting Aside of Judgment or Grant
of New Trial on Payment of Opposing Attorney's Fees, 21 A.L.R. 2d
863 (1952). The federal courts have also taken the same approach
in issuing relief pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b).
See Annotation, Propriety of Conditions Imposed In Granting Relief
From Judgment Under Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b), 3 A.L.R. Fed.
956 (1970); 10A Wright & Miller, Federal Practice and Procedure,
§2700; Thorpe v. Thorpe, 364 F.2d 692, 694 (D.C. Cir. 1966).
As a result, we conclude that the term which will ordinarily suffice
to alleviate any prejudice to the plaintiff is the reimbursement
of plaintiff's fees and expenses as a condition of vacating the
default judgment. This is particularly true where the judgment has
been in effect for only a brief period of time before the motion
to vacate is filed. In that circumstance, a plaintiff's expectations
regarding the legitimacy of the judgment and the court's interest
in the finality of judgments are at their nadir. Accordingly, in
most cases the only terms which are, in the words of R. 4:50-1,
"just" are those which restore plaintiff to the status
quo ante, namely the reimbursement of the fees and costs expended
in seeking the default judgment and in opposing the motion to vacate.
As set forth in Pressler. Current NJ Court Rules, Comment R 4:50-1
(Gann) in setting aside a default judgment, the court may impose
terms, including the award of counsel fees for obtaining the default
judgment and defending the motion to set aside.
CONCLUSION: If facing a civil suit, immediately consult with a
civil attorney to prevent a default from being entered against you.
CALL KENNETH A. VERCAMMEN, ESQ. 732-572-0500 for an appointment
About Kenneth Vercammen:
Kenneth Vercammen is a Litigation Attorney in Edison, NJ, approximately
17 miles north of Princeton. He often lectures for the New Jersey
State Bar Association on personal injury, criminal / municipal court
law and drunk driving.
He has published 125 articles in national and New Jersey publications
on municipal court and litigation topics. He has served as a Special
Acting Prosecutor in seven different cities and towns in New Jersey
and also successfully defended hundreds of individuals facing Municipal
Court and Criminal Court charges.
In his private practice, he has devoted a substantial portion of
his professional time to the preparation and trial of litigated
matters. He has appeared in Courts throughout New Jersey several
times each week on many personal injury matters, Municipal Court
trials, hearings and contested administrative law hearings.
Since 1985, his primary concentration has been on litigation matters.
Mr. Vercammen gained other legal experiences as the Confidential
Law Clerk to the Court of Appeals of Maryland (Supreme Court), with
the Delaware County, PA District Attorney Office handling Probable
Cause Hearings, Middlesex County Probation Dept as a Probation Officer,
and an Executive Assistant to Scranton District Magistrate, Thomas
Hart, in Scranton, PA.
|